Study finds “very weak” case for funded pensions

EUROPE - A new academic study has found a "very weak" theoretical case for funded pension schemes over traditional pay-as-you-go systems.

And the authors reject the idea that PAYG will not be viable in the near future - and recommend reforming standard PAYG.

"Longer life expectancy and lower fertility rates will lead to an ageing population in most Western countries," say Eladio Febrero and María-Ángeles Cadarso of the Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha.

"This is thought to make earnings-based defined-benefit pay-as-you-go pension schemes unviable in the near future."

Febrero and Cadarso note that some economists suggest shifting towards a capitalized funded system, a proposal grounded in three advantages. These are: (i) it raises national saving, thus leading to a faster rate of accumulation and a larger per capita income; (ii) it offers a higher rate of return on savings; (iii) it is immune to demographic shifts.

"In this paper we explore the fundamentals of these advantages, and conclude that the theoretical basis supporting them is very weak," Eladio Febrero A1 and María-Ángeles Cadarso say.

The comments come in ‘Pay-As-You-Go versus funded systems. Some critical considerations'. They go against some of the received opinion in the pensions industry - just last month, UK Pension Commission chairman likened PAYG to "pyramid selling" schemes.

"We base our theoretical standpoint on the Sraffian-based capital critique and the theory of endogenous money," the researchers say.

"Additionally, we defend a parametric reform of a standard PAYG using figures that correspond to the Spanish economy for the period 2001-70."

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment


Your first step in manager selection...

IPE Quest is a manager search facility that connects institutional investors and asset managers.

  • QN-2503

    Asset class: Equities.
    Asset region: Emerging Markets.
    Size: EUR 30m.
    Closing date: 2019-01-31.

  • QN-2505

    Asset class: Real Estate Core/Core-Plus Multi-sector strategy.
    Asset region: Asia-Pacific.
    Size: $ 50m.
    Closing date: 2019-01-28.

Begin Your Search Here