mast image

Special Report

Impact investing

Sections

Trustees don’t understand investment (update)

UK – An academic study supported by the National Association of Pension Funds has found that trustees have no common understanding of the principles of investment theory and practice (Updates to include further comment).

It found they are prone to the same “cognitive anomalies” as the rest of the population.

“Put simply, trustees do not share a common understanding of the most important (albeit abstract) principles underpinning modern investment theory and practice,” the Oxford University researchers write.

The comments come in the 32-page ‘Pension fund trustee competence: decision-making in problems relevant to investment practice’ by Gordon L. Clark, Emiko Caerlewy-Smith and John C. Marshall.

They add their findings about trustees’ decision-making were “troubling” as the range of their solutions to problems was far greater than anticipated.

“It is clear, based on our experimental strategy, that pension fund trustees are prone to the cognitive anomalies and biases that researchers in psychology have attributed to the population at large,” state the Oxford University researchers.

They tested 40 trustees of defined benefit pension funds, sourced via the NAPF, alongside 80 Oxford undergraduates as a reference point.

“As expected, pension fund decision-making was shown to be less than ideal… trustees are nothing like the super-human calculating machines” of economic theory, the academics write. They add that trustees do not use the available data in an efficient manner to test solutions to problems.

“If indicative of the nature and range of trustee decision-making, these results have important implications for the coherence of collective decision-making and the role of fund advisors and service providers,” the authors state.

Professor Clark said: “The NAPF does not endorse the views expressed in the paper nor does it represent official NAPF policy.

“The views expressed in the paper are, as indicated in the paper, solely the responsibility of the authors. The paper is based on data collected and should not be construed as representing the entire universe of trustees or average trustee competence.”

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

IPE QUEST

Your first step in manager selection...

IPE Quest is a manager search facility that connects institutional investors and asset managers.

  • QN-2548

    Asset class: Fixed Income, Emerging Market Debt Hard Currency (Active).
    Asset region: Emerging Markets.
    Size: CHF 300-400m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-30.

  • QN-2549

    Asset class: Fixed Income, Emerging Market Debt Hard Currency (Passive or Passive Enhanced).
    Asset region: Emerging Markets.
    Size: CHF 300-700m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-30.

  • QN-2550

    Asset class: Fixed Income, Emerging Market Debt Local Currency (Active).
    Asset region: Emerging Markets.
    Size: CHF 250-350m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-31.

  • QN-2551

    Asset class: Fixed Income, Emerging Market Debt Local Currency (Passive or Passive Enhanced).
    Asset region: Emerging Markets.
    Size: CHF 250-350m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-31.

  • QN-2552

    Asset class: Fixed Income, High Yield (Active).
    Asset region: High Yield (US).
    Size: CHF 500-600m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-29.

  • QN-2553

    Asset class: Fixed Income, High Yield (Passive or Passive Enhanced).
    Asset region: High Yield (US).
    Size: CHF 500-1'100m.
    Closing date: 2019-07-29.

  • QN-2554

    Asset class: Global Real Estate (Equity, unlisted Funds).
    Asset region: World (ex-Switzerland).
    Size: CHF 200 mn (potential for further growth).
    Closing date: 2019-08-07.

  • QN-2555

    Asset class: Real Estate.
    Asset region: European.
    Size: EUR 50 - 100 million.
    Closing date: 2019-07-22.

  • QN-2556

    Asset class: FX Hedging.
    Asset region: Global.
    Size: Mandate size of CHF 1.5 bn.
    Closing date: 2019-08-09.

  • QN-2557

    Asset class: All/large Cap Equities.
    Asset region: China A-shares.
    Size: Unit linked platform (0m USD in initial investment).
    Closing date: 2019-08-01.

Begin Your Search Here
<