German pension funds are calling for changes to key aspects of the European Commission’s proposed reform of the IORP II Directive, raising concerns over investment rules, consolidation and new stress-testing requirements.

Christian Röhle, head of pension fund management and law at the pension fund for employees of the Hoechst Group, said institutions for occupational retirement provision (IORPs) are “well-suited” to support Europe’s economy through the Savings and Investments Union (SIU).

However, he described the Commission’s proposals as “counterproductive”, arguing that “we need appropriate framework conditions,” he told IPE.

Röhle questioned whether the proposed changes to investment regulations and measures to encourage consolidation would deliver the intended benefits for German IORPs.

Consolidation provides “no added value” in Germany, he said.

Investment rules should “remain as they are”, he added, advocating the retention of clearly defined investment quotas for German Pensionskassen, which manage approximately €210bn in assets.

The Commission’s proposals, by contrast, seek to give pension providers greater investment flexibility through the prudent person principle.

Beatrix Tröger, director pensions at Bosch Pensionsfonds, also raised concerns about the Commission’s proposals, particularly provisions allowing delegated acts to modify quantitative investment requirements and solvency rules for IORPs “at any time”.

Speaking at the Handelsblatt occupational pension forum in Berlin last week, Tröger argued that this would undermine the principle of minimum harmonisation and “does not fit within a stable framework and clear planning horizon” required by IORPs.

Christian Röhle (Hoechst) and Beatrix Tröger (Bosch) at Handelsblatt Berlin Nov 2026

Christian Röhle (Hoechst) and Beatrix Tröger (Bosch) at Handelsblatt conference in Berlin

She also criticised the proposed Article 18a, which introduces additional stress-testing requirements for defined benefit (DB) schemes.

Under the proposals, DB schemes “without risk-based capital requirements” would be required to conduct stress tests at least every three years, covering four prescribed scenarios over a 10-year horizon, she explained.

“Forecasts suggest that hardly any German pension institution (IORPs) would pass these stress scenarios,” Tröger said.

She added that current calculations suggest approximately 17% more equity capital would be needed to pass the tests.

“We would advocate for erasing the article,” she added.

The concerns come ahead of trilogue negotiations between the European Parliament, the Council of the EU and the European Commission, which are expected to begin in January 2027.

The European Parliament’s Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs (ECON) agreed its negotiating position last month, calling for risk assessment requirements to remain proportionate to the nature, scale and complexity of IORPs.

According to German media reports, ECON also supports removing restrictive national rules governing investments in certain asset classes, although Germany’s Investment Regulation (Anlageverordnung), which sets defined investment quotas, would remain in force.

The Council of the EU adopted its position on the IORP II review in June.